My name is Patrik Hutzel from intensivecarehotline.com, and this is another quick tip for families in intensive care. At intensivecarehotline.com, we improve the lives for families of critically ill patients in intensive care instantly so that you can make informed decisions, have peace of mind, control, power and influence, making sure your loved one always gets best care and treatment, even if you’re not a doctor or a nurse in intensive care.

Today I want to answer a question from Tracey, whose aunt is currently in the ICU following carotid artery surgery, a hemorrhagic stroke, and two brain bleeds — the second of which the surgical team felt was not suitable for repeat surgery. Tracey’s aunt has been off sedation for a week, is showing some hand movement, but cannot open her eyes. The family is now being asked to decide about a tracheostomy.

Tracey’s core question — and it is one of the most important questions any ICU family can ask — is this:

“If she receives a tracheostomy and does not show meaningful improvement, will the medical team still allow natural death to occur? Does a tracheostomy commit us to indefinite life support?”

This is an incredibly important question, and I want to give you a thorough, honest answer — because this is exactly the kind of situation where families are left in the dark, and where having the right information and the right support can make all the difference.

What Has Happened Medically — and Why It Matters

Carotid Artery Surgery and Hemorrhagic Stroke

Carotid artery surgery — typically a carotid endarterectomy or stenting — is performed to reduce stroke risk by clearing or opening a narrowed artery. However, in a small number of cases, the surgery itself can trigger a hemorrhagic (bleeding) stroke. This is a serious complication where blood leaks into the brain tissue rather than flowing through blood vessels.

Two Brain Bleeds — The Second Too Risky for Surgery

Tracey’s aunt had the first hemorrhage managed with brain surgery to remove the blood clot. When a second hemorrhage occurred, the surgical team determined she was not a candidate for a repeat operation. This is a significant clinical decision. Repeat brain surgery in this context carries an extremely high risk of death or further catastrophic neurological damage, and the team made the judgment that the risks outweighed the benefits.

One Week Without Sedation — Showing Hand Movement

This is an important detail. After one week without sedation or pain medication, the brain is no longer suppressed by drugs. Any responses you see now are the brain’s own activity — not sedation effects. Tracey’s aunt is showing some response with one hand. She cannot open her eyes.

What Does This Mean Clinically? Hand movement without eye opening one-week post-injury, off all sedation, suggests there is some preserved brain activity — but the picture is incomplete. This does not necessarily mean recovery is impossible, nor does it guarantee meaningful recovery. Neurological trajectories after hemorrhagic stroke are notoriously difficult to predict in the early weeks. Brain imaging, electroencephalograph (EEG), and neurological assessments over time are critical to understanding the prognosis. This is exactly why getting all the medical records and imaging results is so important.

Why You Absolutely Need Access to ALL Medical Records Right Now

Before you make any decision — about the tracheostomy or anything else — you and your family need to have complete access to your aunt’s medical records. This means:

• All CT scans and MRI reports — to see exactly where the bleeds occurred and how much brain tissue was affected
• All neurological assessments — Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) scores, pupil responses, motor responses at each assessment
• The surgical reports — to understand exactly what was done in both surgeries
• Nursing notes and ICU progress notes — day by day since admission
• Any specialist consultations — neurology, neurosurgery, and any others involved in her care

Why does this matter so much? Because families are routinely making life-and-death decisions without ever seeing the full picture. The medical team gives you summaries — but summaries leave out critical details. When you have the actual records, you can ask specific, informed questions. You can identify whether the prognosis the team is presenting is based on solid evidence — or on assumptions.

At Intensive Care Hotline, we review medical records with families every day. We have seen cases where families were told a situation was hopeless — and the records told a different story. We have also seen cases where the records confirmed what the team was saying. Either way, you deserve to know the truth — and the truth lives in the records.

Does a Tracheostomy Lock You into Indefinite Life Support?

The short answer is NO. A tracheostomy does not automatically commit you to indefinite life support.

But let me explain this properly, because the nuance matters enormously.

What a Tracheostomy Actually Is

A tracheostomy is a surgical opening made in the front of the neck, through which a tube is inserted directly into the trachea (windpipe) to allow breathing — either with or without a mechanical ventilator. It replaces the oral breathing tube (endotracheal tube) that is placed through the mouth during initial resuscitation.

A tracheostomy is typically recommended when:

• A patient is expected to need ventilator support for more than a few weeks
• Weaning from the ventilator is slow or uncertain
• The patient needs airway protection but may not need full ventilator support
• Oral tube removal is planned but respiratory function is not yet sufficient

What a Tracheostomy Does NOT Do

A tracheostomy does not: •  Change the patient’s underlying diagnosis or prognosis •  Legally or ethically bind the family or the medical team to continued life support •  Remove your right — or the medical team’s ability — to redirect goals of care toward comfort and dignity •  Commit your loved one to a ventilator forever

In medical and ethical terms, the placement of a tracheostomy is a reversible intervention. It can be removed. Ventilator support can be withdrawn. Goals of care can be redirected at any time — before or after a tracheostomy — if the family and the medical team reach an agreement that further treatment is not in the patient’s best interest or does not align with the patient’s previously expressed wishes.

So Why Is the Tracheostomy Decision So Difficult?

Because it feels permanent. It is a visible, surgical commitment that the body will need ongoing respiratory support. Families worry — rightly — that once the tracheostomy is in place, the team will be less willing to discuss withdrawal. And sometimes, those concerns are valid.

This is exactly why I always tell families: the conversation about goals of care needs to happen before the tracheostomy is placed — not after. You need the team to clearly articulate what happens if she does not improve. You need to discuss the threshold for reassessment. You need to know what the team considers a meaningful recovery — and whether that aligns with what your aunt wanted.

The question to ask the ICU team before agreeing to a tracheostomy: “If she receives a tracheostomy and her neurological condition does not show meaningful improvement over the next four to eight weeks — what happens then? Will you support a decision to redirect care toward comfort? Will ventilator support be withdrawn if that is what the family decides, in alignment with her wishes?” Get the answer to that question in writing, or at minimum, documented in the medical record as part of a family meeting note.

What Are the Treatment Options Right Now?

Let me walk through the realistic options Tracey’s family is facing, so you have a clear framework for the decisions ahead.

Option 1: Proceed with Tracheostomy and Ongoing Ventilator Support

This is the option the team appears to be recommending. The rationale is that:

• A tracheostomy is safer and more comfortable for long-term use than an oral tube
• It gives the brain more time to show its recovery trajectory
• It keeps all future options open — including weaning, rehabilitation, and home discharge

This option does not mean committing to indefinite life support. It means buying time — and time is what the brain needs to demonstrate whether meaningful recovery is possible.

Option 2: Tracheostomy with a Defined Review Timeline

This is the approach I strongly recommend families negotiate. The family agrees to the tracheostomy on the condition that a formal goals-of-care review is scheduled — for example, at four weeks and again at eight weeks — where the team will honestly reassess her neurological trajectory, discuss prognosis openly, and support a decision to redirect to comfort care if she has not shown meaningful improvement.

This is not a guarantee. But it is a documented, agreed-upon framework that protects the family from feeling trapped.

Option 3: Decline the Tracheostomy and Redirect to Comfort Care Now

If the family determines — based on the aunt’s previously expressed wishes, values, and the medical prognosis — that continued aggressive treatment is not what she would have wanted, then declining the tracheostomy and transitioning to comfort care is a legitimate and compassionate option.

This does not mean abandoning her. It means shifting the focus to dignity, comfort, pain management, and a peaceful death — rather than indefinite technology-supported life. The oral tube can be removed, ventilator support withdrawn, and palliative medications given to ensure she does not suffer.

There is no wrong answer here — only the answer that is right for your aunt and your family. What matters is that the decision is informed — that you have the full clinical picture, that you understand every option, and that your aunt’s voice (whether expressed directly or through those who know her best) is at the center of the decision.

What If She Needs Long-Term Ventilation? Intensive Care at Home Is an Option

If Tracey’s aunt does receive a tracheostomy and her condition stabilizes — but she remains ventilator-dependent and cannot be weaned — there is an option that most families are never told about: Intensive Care at Home.

Intensive Care at Home is Australia’s only third-party accredited specialist home nursing provider for ventilator-dependent adults and children. We are ISO 9001:2015 certified and NDIS Quality and Safety Commission accredited. We have over 150 Critical Care Registered Nurses operating across all states and territories.

We specialize in caring for patients with:

• Invasive ventilation via tracheostomy — long-term or permanent
• Non-invasive ventilation (BiPAP/CPAP) for patients who cannot maintain their own breathing
• Complex neurological conditions including stroke, Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI), and neuromuscular disease
• Palliative ventilation — for patients and families who want comfort care delivered at home rather than in the ICU
• If you’re in the US/ Canada or the UK please contact us as well, we can help you there as well!

Why Does This Matter for Tracey’s Family? If Tracey’s aunt stabilizes on a tracheostomy and ventilator — even if she has significant neurological impairment — she does not have to remain in the ICU indefinitely. With the right nursing support, she can be discharged home. This keeps her out of ICU predictably and permanently, surrounds her with family, dramatically reduces the cost of care compared to ongoing ICU admission, and can be provided within an NDIS-funded framework for eligible patients. Visit www.intensivecareathome.com to learn more.

How Intensive Care Hotline Can Help Tracey’s Family Right Now

At Intensive Care Hotline, we work with ICU families in exactly this situation every day. Here is what we can do for you:

• Review all your aunt’s medical records with you — so you understand exactly what has happened and what the records actually say about her prognosis
• Join a call with the ICU team on your behalf — to ask the questions that families don’t know to ask, and to advocate for a goals-of-care framework that protects your family
• Help you understand your rights — including your right to second opinions, to request specialist neurology consultations, and to have documented goals-of-care conversations
• Help navigate the tracheostomy decision — so you make the choice that is right for your aunt, not the choice that is easiest for the hospital
• Connect with Intensive Care at Home — if long-term or palliative ventilation care at home becomes the right path forward

Get Immediate Help from Patrik and the Intensive Care Hotline Team If your loved one is in ICU right now and you need answers, clarity, and real advocacy — we are here for you at www.intensivecarehotline.com

Summary: What Tracey’s Family Needs to Know

• A tracheostomy does not lock you into indefinite life support — goals of care can always be redirected
• Before agreeing to a tracheostomy, negotiate a defined review timeline and get the team’s answer documented about what happens if she does not improve
• You need access to all medical records— imaging, neurological assessments, surgical reports, and nursing notes — before making any decision
• Consulting with an independent ICU expert can help you understand the full picture and advocate effectively
• If long-term ventilation becomes the outcome, Intensive Care at Home can discharge her from the ICU to a home environment with full specialist nursing support
• There are always options — even when it feels like there are none

For more information, visit www.intensivecarehotline.com or www.intensivecareathome.com

I have worked in critical care nursing for 25 years in three different countries where I worked as a nurse manager for over 5 years in intensive care. I’ve been consulting and advocating for families in intensive care since 2013 here at intensivecarehotline.com. I can very confidently say that we have saved many lives with our consulting and advocacy because of our insights. You can verify that on our testimonial section at intensivecarehotline.com. You can verify it on our intensivecarehotline.com podcast section where we have done client interviews because our advice is absolutely life changing.

The biggest challenge for families in intensive care is simply that they don’t know what they don’t know. They don’t know what to look for. They don’t know what questions to ask. They don’t know their rights, and they don’t know how to manage doctors and nurses in intensive care.

That’s why we help you to improve your life instantly, making sure you make informed decisions, have peace of mind, control, power, and influence, making sure your loved one gets best care and treatment always. That’s why you can join a growing number of members and clients that we have helped over the years, saving their loved ones’ lives.

That’s why I do one on one consulting and advocacy over the phone, Zoom, WhatsApp, whichever medium works best for you. I talk to you and your families directly. I handhold you through this once in a lifetime situation that you simply cannot afford to get wrong. When I talk to families directly, I also talk to doctors and nurses directly, asking all the questions that you haven’t even considered asking but must be asked when you have a loved one critically ill in intensive care.

I also represent you in family meetings with intensive care teams.

We also do medical record reviews in real time so that you can get a second opinion in real time. We also do medical record reviews after intensive care if in case you have unanswered questions, if you need closure, or if you are suspecting medical negligence.

We also have a membership for families of critically ill patients in intensive care, and you can become a member if you go to intensivecarehotline.com, if you click on the membership link, or if you go to intensivecaresupport.org directly. In the membership, you have access to me and my team, 24 hours a day, in the membership area and via email, and we answer all questions intensive care related. In the membership, you also have exclusive access to 21 eBooks and 21 videos that I have personally written and recorded. All of that will help you to improve your life instantly, make informed decisions, have peace of mind, control, power and influence, making sure your loved one gets best care and treatment always.

All of that you get at intensivecarehotline.com. Call us on one of the numbers on the top of our website or simply send us an email to [email protected] with your questions.

If you like my videos, subscribe to my YouTube channel for regular updates for families in intensive care. Click the like button, click the notification bell, share the video with your friends and families, and comment below what you want to see next, what questions and insights you have from this video.

I also do a weekly YouTube live where I answer your questions live on the show. You will get notification for the YouTube live if you are a subscriber to my YouTube channel or my intensivecarehotline.com email newsletter at intensivecarehotline.com.

Thank you so much for watching.

This is Patrik Hutzel from intensivecarehotline.com and I will talk to you in a few days.

Take care for now.